Macedonia-Evidence
The cultural milieu
of the Macedonian court was Greek
By Frank L. Holt (*)
Professor of Ancient History University
of Houston
Μακεδονίαν καί τήν άλλην Ελλάδα
Arrian
The documents comprising this book speak forcefully for the proposition
that the history of ancient Macedonia, including the brilliant reigns of Philip
and his son Alexander, belongs squarely in the cultural, economic, political,
religious, and military history of Hellenism.
The cultural milieu of the
Macedonian court was Greek.
The texts that Alexander studied as a youth were
Greek.
The books he read while in Asia were Greek.
The heroes he emulated, the
gods he worshipped, the temples he built were Greek.
The coins he minted in the
millions were Greek.
The legacy he left behind from Anatolia to India was as
Greek as his settlers could make it, right down to a theater, gymnasium, and
inscribed copy of the Delphic maxims in a far corner of Afghanistan. To say
that Alexander’s kingdom was in some ways out of step with the city-states to
the south is hardly an argument against his Hellenic heritage; it only means
that Macedonia remained more Homeric than Athens, Thebes, or Sparta. It is hard
to be more Greek than that. Nor should we be troubled by Alexander’s ability to
speak a Macedonian dialect or by his interest in the world beyond Greece
itself. Alexander was a man of the world, certainly, but he was a man from
Macedonian Greece. According to Arrian 2.14.4, Alexander said this himself in a
letter to the Persian king Darius:
Alexander sent a reply to Darius by way of Thersippos, who went back
with the Persian envoys. Alexander’s letter states as follows: “Your ancestors
invaded Macedonia and the rest of Greece, inflicting evils upon us without
provocation…”
Here Alexander’s point seems clear—Macedonia was historically a part of
Greece.
A widening academic consensus on this matter may be witnessed among the
many signatories to another epistle of more recent composition, addressed to
President Barack Obama. That letter, too, cites history in order to show the
connection between Macedonia and the rest of Greece. This unusual appeal to an
American leader arises from a decision by the United States to recognize as the
‘Republic of Macedonia’, with all of its historic implications, what had
previously been called the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, or Skopje.
But why should a decision of this kind stir a strong reaction, particularly
among ‘ivory-tower’ academics? Is not the new name just an economy of words?
Does not every nation have the sovereign right to adopt any name it chooses?
Not really, for in many cases claims follow names: historic, ethnic, and even
territorial.
The crux lies less in the politics of 2004, when a former administration
took this action, than in the pages of a work whose title bears a date twenty
years earlier. In George Orwell’s 1984, penned in 1948 by an author aware of
why words and ideas matter, the motto of Big Brother and his insidious Ministry
of Information highlights the dangers of historical distortion: Who controls
the past controls the future; who controls the present controls the past. Real
power resides not in the technologies of war or totalitarianism, but rather in
that ancient invention of the Greeks called history. The past matters, and more
than most people in Orwell’s world—or ours—may realize. The future surely
fascinates us, but it has no force. It merely waits while the past drives the
present. On the train-tracks of time, the engine has always been in the back,
pushing rather than pulling. Thus, the past cannot be unhooked and unheeded as
so much dead weight. Nor can it be left in the hands of the wrong engineers:
Whoever controls the past determines the future, and that ultimately depends
upon who in the present is shaping the past. Parliaments? Pundits? Preachers?
Poets? Presidents? Who controls the present must choose carefully whom to trust
with our past, else a false and monstrous future may result. At the very least,
Mr. Presidents and Madam Secretaries and Peoples of the World, please consider
carefully the contents of this book and the credentials of those who have
contributed to it.
(*) This is Prof. Holt's Prologue from the book
"Macedonia-Evidence".
ΛΕΞΕΙΣ-ΚΛΕΙΔΙΑ: ΦΙΛΙΠΠΟΣ, ΜΑΚΕΔΟΝΙΑ, ΜΑΚΕΔΟΝΙΚΟ, ΣΚΟΠΙΑ, ΣΚΟΠΙΑΝΟ, ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΟΣ, ΘΕΡΣΙΠΠΟΣ, ΑΣΙΑ, ΑΦΓΑΝΙΣΤΑΝ, ΔΑΡΕΙΟΣ
ΣΧΟΛΙΑ
ΣΧΟΛΙΑ ΜΕΣΩ Facebook